focus, journal, notes, notebook, planning, journaling, focus, focus, focus, focus, focus, journal, journal, journal, planning, planning, planning, planning, journaling, journaling, journaling, journaling. Social influence basics exercises: the version that survives contact with reality
Photo by Melanie_HH on Pixabay

Reviews

Part of The three channels that carry social influence, explained plainly

Social influence basics exercises: the version that survives contact with reality

Social influence basics exercises: eight drills, a four-week schedule to run them on, and an honest account of what practice here will not fix.

Knowing how influence works changes very little on its own. What changes things is a handful of habits, and habits are built by repetition rather than by reading. The eight drills below take a week each. None needs equipment, and two need a second person.

What to take away

  • Each drill trains one specific skillcounting sources, holding a view against a room, separating a person from their proposal, or letting pressure decay overnight.
  • The measure of success is not feeling different. It is a log entry that shows you did the thing when it mattered.
  • Run them in order for the first month, then keep whichever one caught you out most.

The drills

1. The origin log

For one week, whenever you act on a belief because somebody told you, write down who, and what they had actually seen. Not what they said; what they saw.

By Friday you will have a list of beliefs, most with a short chain that ends in a real observation. One or two will end in "someone told them." Those are the ones to check.

Trains: counting origins rather than voices, the core skill of informational influence. Good result: finding one confidently held belief with no origin at all.

2. Say it first

In every meeting or group decision this week, write down your view before anyone speaks. One line. Then listen. At the end, compare what you wrote with what you said.

Trains: independence from the room, the defense against normative influence. Good result: a gap between the two, noticed. The gap is normal; the noticing is the skill.

3. The disclosure rehearsal

Before you try to persuade anyone of anything this week, write the sentence you would use afterward. Explain exactly what you did and why it worked: "I told you about the deadline because it is real and I thought you would want to know."

If it feels comfortable, proceed. If you find yourself softening it, stop and ask what you were about to hide.

Trains: applying the site's test to yourself, which is harder than applying it to others. Good result: one attempt abandoned or changed because the sentence would not come out straight.

4. The overnight rule

Any decision with a clock attached gets a night, without exception, for one week. Before sleeping, write one line: how sure you are and why. In the morning, write it again. Keep both.

Trains: watching the effects of delivery decay while the effects of substance stay. Good result: a pair of entries that disagree. You will not need convincing after the first one.

5. The transfer

Take a proposal from someone you like, and re-read it as if it came from someone you find tiresome. Read it in their voice. Note what is left.

Trains: separating the person from the proposal, the habit that defends against the liking principle. Good result: a proposal that shrank, and an honest account of what shrank it.

6. Assigned opposition

Needs a partner. Pick a decision you both favor. One of you argues against it for ten minutes, as well as you can, whether or not you believe a word. The role of the devil's advocate is old precisely because the argument nobody wants to make is the one that gets skipped.

Trains: hearing the objection before it is expensive. Good result: an objection neither of you had considered, said aloud, and the decision either strengthened or changed.

7. The pre-mortem

Needs a partner, or a notebook. Assume the decision was made and, a year on, has gone badly. Write the story of why, as a history rather than a warning. The pre-mortem works because imagining a failure that has already happened produces specific causes, where imagining a failure that might happen produces reassurance.

Trains: noticing what the persuasion left out. Good result: one cause in the story that was not in the pitch.

8. Three names

Whenever "everyone", "most people" or "nobody" is used to move you this week, ask for three names, politely, of yourself if nobody else is there. Count how often three arrive.

Trains: telling a count from a mood. Good result: the phrase losing its force, because you now hear it as a claim.

A four-week schedule

WeekSoloWith a partner
OneOrigin log, three names
TwoSay it first, overnight rule
ThreeDisclosure rehearsal, the transfer
FourAssigned opposition, pre-mortem

Two drills a week is enough. Running all eight at once produces a week of self-observation and no habit.

Four-week drill schedule

  1. Week one
    Origin log, three names
  2. Week two
    Say it first, overnight rule
  3. Week three
    Disclosure rehearsal, the transfer
  4. Week four
    Assigned opposition, pre-mortem

What the drills do not do

They do not make you immune. The feelings that tactics produce (obligation, urgency, the wish not to be the odd one out) still arrive on schedule, in everyone, including people who have run these drills for years.

What the drills change is what happens in the second after the feeling: a name for it, and a step already decided on. That is the whole of what manipulation resistance amounts to in practice, and the wider framework the drills are built on is set out in social influence basics.

Common questions

Which drill first, if only one?

The overnight rule. It is the simplest, it costs nothing, and the first pair of disagreeing entries teaches more than any explanation.

Do I need a partner?

For six of the eight, no. For the two that need one, a colleague or a friend who will take the assignment seriously is enough; expertise is not required.

How long before it becomes a habit?

Longer than a week, which is why the schedule is a start and not a course. Keep the log. A drill you can see yourself having done is one you are more likely to do again.

What if I catch myself using a tactic on someone?

Then drill three worked. Say what you were doing, out loud, to the person. It is uncomfortable once and instructive for a long time.

More in Reviews

Latest from Policy Desk